Cruise control for your hot-water heating system

Last week I talked about how sustained flue-gas condensation can shorten the useful life of a cast-iron hot water boiler. Today I’d like to share with you my favorite method for preventing flue-gas condensation while making your home more efficient and comfortable.

The goal of any control and/or piping strategy designed to eliminate sustained flue-gas condensation in a cast-iron boiler is to maintain the return water temperature above the dew point of the flue gasses. With natural gas this dew point is typically 130˚ - 140˚F. There are several variables that contribute to the returning water temperature and to the flue-gas temperatures. These include the type of room heat emitter, the volume of water in the system, the size of the boiler (as compared to the heat load) and the ambient combustion air temperature, to name just a few. All of these variables are unique from system to system. They can also change from cycle to cycle in the same system.

Here’s an example: Let’s say you have a system with cast-iron radiators and large distribution piping. This may originally have been a gravity hot water system from the early 20th century. There’s lots of water and metal to heat up in a system like this. Let’s also imagine it's a been a sunny but cool day so your home has benefited from solar gain during the day and the boiler hasn't fired for hours because the thermostat is in that south- or west-facing dining room. The sun goes down, the dining room cools, the thermostat calls for heat and your boiler fires up.

Now think about the water inside your heating system. It’s been sitting there all day in the cold pipes and radiators. It can’t be any warmer than the air in your house or basement — probably 60˚ - 70˚F. It starts to circulate through the boiler, the piping and the radiators. Maybe it runs for a half hour or so, and the boiler manages to heat the water up to about 80˚ or 90˚F. (Remember, flue gasses are condensing this whole time.) Then the thermostat becomes satisfied and the boiler shuts off.

An hour later the thermostat calls for heat again. This time the system warms the water a little more — but still not to the point where condensation is eliminated.

These cycles continue throughout night with each subsequent cycle warming the water a little more, until finally it reaches a point where the return water temperature rises above the flue gas dew-point. Most of the cycles in this particular (but very common) example share the fact that they’re producing low return-water temperatures. It’s the temperature of the returning water that changes from cycle to cycle.

What’s needed to prevent this condensing condition is a control and piping arrangement that can adjust itself dynamically to the changing system conditions. I’ve found that a variable-speed injection-mixing system works perfectly in this situation.

Injection mixing controller

It involves some piping changes near your boiler and the addition of a small, electronic controller to manage the temperatures and control a mixing circulator. The system piping is separated into two loops — a primary loop out of the boiler and back in, and a secondary loop that just circulates water out to the radiators and back. Then I connect those two loops with a piping “bridge,” and hot water from the primary (boiler) loop is “injected” into the secondary (distribution) loop. The controller monitors the temperatures of both loops and adjusts the rate of injection in order to maintain a minimum boiler-loop temperature. It does this by speeding up or slowing down the circulator in the “bridge” to let the boiler catch up to the distribution system’s ability to take the heat away. The beauty of this system is that it can automatically adjust for varying system conditions and provide continuous boiler protection.

Another feature of the electronic controller is its ability to adjust the boiler and the system water temperature in relation to the outdoor temperature. This is called outdoor-reset control. A sensor reads the outdoor temperature and feeds that information back to the controller which then determines the temperature water needed to heat your house at that moment. It can allow the secondary (distribution) water temperature to modulate between, say, 70˚ on a warm day and 160˚ on a cold night. It will also modulate the boiler’s set-point temperature while never letting it drop below its condensing temperature. It’s like cruise control for your heating system — just the right amount of heat at the right time with long, low-temperature cycles.

Outdoor-reset control can save a significant amount of fuel, especially in the “shoulder” seasons when your boiler’s full output isn’t needed.  It will also make your home more comfortable. By lowering the distribution water temperature, each heating cycle is longer and the room temperature swings are minimal, making you more comfortable.

If you have a home that’s heated by a cast-iron boiler and has a high-mass distribution system (such as cast-iron radiators or radiant heat in a concrete floor), you will benefit from this control strategy. Longer boiler life, lower fuel cost and more comfort is a win, win, win!

Heidronically yours,

Wayne

How to kill a workhorse

The vast majority of residential hot water boilers in service today are cast-iron mid-efficiency boilers. These are the workhorses of the hydronic industry and have been for many years. Installed and maintained properly, they can provide reliable service for 30 years or more. They typically have efficiency ratings in the low 80% range, meaning about 80 cents of every fuel dollar spent is converted to useable heat. The rest is lost up the chimney.

Older cast-iron water boilers from the early part of the 1900s were larger and held more water volume than today’s models. While this larger volume of water acted as a buffer and helped to smooth out some of the variability in water temperatures, it was at the expense of some efficiency. Today’s cast-iron boilers are smaller, and consequentially more efficient, but are less forgiving when it comes to handling low water temperatures.

Sustained low water temperatures can cause flue gasses inside the boiler to cool to the point that they condense on the relatively cool cast-iron heat-exchanger surfaces. This condensate is corrosive and will attack the bare metal surfaces of the boiler, creating rust and scale that can plug flue passageways and interfere with the operation of the burner. At its worst, this condition will allow dangerous products of combustion to enter your home. But at a minimum, it will shorten the useful life of your boiler. Today’s cast-iron boilers need to maintain water temperatures above the 130° - 140°F temperature range to prevent flue gas condensation.

The key to maintaining these safe water temperatures lies in your boiler's ability to produce heat at a faster rate than your house can use it.

Copper finned-tube baseboard

An example of a system that would work well is a home with copper finned-tube baseboard and small copper distribution piping. Many homes built in the 50s and 60s fit this description. Considered a “low-mass” distribution system, its copper tubing and light-weight baseboard emitters heat up quickly. These systems are usually designed for fairly high operating temperatures—typically 180°F. Assuming the boiler is sized properly to the home’s heat loss, it can come up to temperature quickly and has no trouble staying ahead of the home’s heating load. Water returning to the boiler will remain above the 130° - 140°F range for most of each heating cycle.

Where flue gas condensation problems start to develop are in high-temperature/high-mass systems, or low-temperature/high- or low-mass systems.

Cast-iron radiator.

A very common high-temperature/high-mass system where sustained flue gas condensation needs to be considered is an older (early 1900s) home with cast-iron radiators and large steel distribution piping. There are literally tons of cast iron and steel, and hundreds of gallons of cold water that need to come up to temperature before the radiators can start heating your rooms. This can easily overwhelm a properly sized boiler and cause it to run at sub-130° temperatures for long periods of time.

Another type of system that can overwhelm a boiler is a radiant in-floor system of tubes in concrete. This one is a one-two punch for your boiler. Not only are these systems designed to run at low water temperatures (110°F is typical) but the entire concrete slab must be heated before it can start delivering room heat. Some of these systems take days to recover from set-back. And the flue gasses are condensing the whole time. It’s a recipe for disaster.

One recent trend I’ve been seeing is for radiant in-floor tubes to be stapled to the underside of the subfloor and connected directly to a cast-iron boiler. This type of installation would typically run at 100° - 130°F water temperatures. The installer simply turns the boiler aquastat, or temperature setting, down to 120° and walks away. This system will likely condense for its entire—albeit short—life.

The effects of flue-gas condensation.

I’ve serviced boilers subjected to these conditions, and believe me, they’re not pretty. Sometimes there are piles of rust on top of the burners.

The good news is there are ways to protect your cast-iron boiler from low return water temperatures, extend its life, improve comfort and reduce your fuel consumption. Next week, I'll tell you my favorite solution to this problem.

Heidronically yours,

Wayne

# 3 - Reliability: Why a hydronic heating system is more reliable than forced air

The reliability of your heating system is something you may take for granted – until it's not working. But  hydronics has a long history of reliable service – even when neglected.

The traditional workhorse of hydronics is the cast-iron boiler. You know – like the one in grandma's basement that's been feeding those big 'ol cast iron radiators you used to put your mittens on after coming inside from a sledding excursion. It you go down there today you may find that same boiler just purring along some 30, 40 or 50 years later. With its massive cast-iron heat exchanger sections, it may still be some time before a leak forces her replacement. (I'm still talking about the boiler here!)

Compare that to the sheet-metal heat exchanger of a forced air furnace and there's not much debate. The heat exchanger of any heating equipment goes through thousands of heat-up and cool-down cycles in its lifetime. Each of these cycles starts to fatigue the metal and bring the furnace one step closer to failure. Compare 1/8" (at most) of a furnace sheet-metal heat exchanger to a 1/2" (or more) of cast iron and you begin to see why grandma's old boiler is still kicking while her neighbor, Myrtle, has had the furnace guys replace a couple of "slip unders" in the same amount of time.

Now, I'm not going to tell you that grandma's 40-year-old boiler is as efficient as a modern replacement boiler, but then she's probably thinking, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it", and, with proper maintenance, that can be good strategy.

But another way a hydronic heating system has it all over forced air is in the reliability of its distribution system. Over time, a furnace duct system can develop leaks and build dust and contaminants that blow throughout your home. A hydronic heating system has a network of pipe or tubing that distributes the heat throughout your home with the same reliability and efficiency today as it did the day it was installed. (I've seen systems installed in the 1920's and even earlier, still moving water from the boiler to the radiators.) The pipes can last this long because, after a few days, all of the oxygen is "boiled" out of the distribution water and it no longer has the capability to corrode the piping's internal walls. And leaking pipes just cry out "fix me!" while a leaking duct can go on leaking energy for years.

Many hydronic system owners also choose to heat their domestic hot water (for showers, clothes washing, etc.) with an indirect water heater. (I'll discuss the many advantages of an indirect water heater in a future installment of Heidronics.) It uses the boiler's capacity to heat hot water for domestic use in a separate tank. Many of these have a lifetime warranty and will be the last water heater you'll ever buy. Compare that to the 12 year national average life span of a traditional gas hot water heater. Now that's reliability!

Even though I've seen plenty of older hydronic systems continue to work for years without regular maintenance it's been my experience that any system will work longer (and more reliably) with scheduled, thorough maintenance performed by a competent service technician.

If you're considering hydronics for your home, be sure to ask the designer and installer what provisions they've included in the design and installation to maximize your new system's reliability.

Next week I'll talk about how versatile a hydronics system is – and how that compares to what a forced air system can (and can't) do.

Hydronically yours,

Wayne